Eagle, WI Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Eagle sits at the southern edge of the Kettle Moraine State Forest in western Waukesha County — a true rural village where Old World Wisconsin, the John Muir Trail system, and the Ice Age Trail are within minutes of residential streets. Buyers here trade suburban density for large lots, forest access, and a quieter pace, with price points that reflect land and space rather than proximity to I-94.

Browse Homes Ask a Local Agent

Trusted advisors for Eagle and Waukesha County buyers & sellers.

  • ✅ Local Realtors and market specialists with live MLS access
  • ✅ Straightforward local guidance from first showing to closing
  • ✅ 1-on-1 guided showings in Eagle, nearby communities, and weekend windows
  • ✅ Eagle-specific pricing, offer, and inspection strategy support
Eagle WI real estate and community guide

Eagle Market Snapshot

Eagle, WI real estate can vary by price range, property condition, school boundaries, commute routes, and inventory at the time you search. Treat these numbers as a starting point near Old World Wisconsin, then ask us for current MLS data before making pricing or offer decisions.

14 active

SFH listings on market now — Eagle 53119 (MLS).

$690K

Avg SFH sold price — June 2026, Eagle 53119 (MLS).

34 days

Avg days on market — last 5 SFH sales, Eagle 53119.

104.8%

List-to-sale ratio — homes selling above asking. Expect competition on well-priced listings.

6 new

New SFH listings added this week — Eagle 53119.

3 sold

SFH sales closed this week — Eagle 53119.

1.1 mo.

Est. months of supply — strong seller’s market (well below 6-mo. equilibrium).

+4.8% YoY

Avg SFH price change, Jan–Jun 2025 vs. Jan–Jun 2026 (MLS).

Need a property-specific read? Request a custom valuation for your Eagle address.

Browse Eagle Properties by Type

Jump directly to the property type you’re looking for — no filters to set.

🏠 Single Family Houses & residential homes 🏢 Condominiums Condo & townhome living 🏘️ Two-Family Duplex & owner-occupied 🌳 Land & Lots Vacant land & build sites 🏗️ Multi-Family 3+ unit investment properties 🏭 Commercial Comm/industrial properties

Start with a Focused Search in Eagle

Jump straight to the Eagle listings that fit your timeline and budget — no filters to build.

🗓️ New This Week Listed in the last 7 days 💰 Under $350K First-time buyer range 🏡 $350K – $600K Move-up buyer range 🏆 $600K+ Premium & lake properties 🔨 New Construction Built in the last few years 📉 Price Reduced Cut in the last 7 days 🌊 Lakefront & Waterfront Lake access properties 🌳 Land & Lots Vacant land & acreage

Why Eagle, WI?

Eagle’s draw is its setting — the Kettle Moraine’s southern unit runs directly through and around town, and Old World Wisconsin sits just outside the village limits. That makes it a strong choice for buyers who prioritize outdoor access and rural character over walkability or suburban amenities. Prices reflect the scale and setting.

  • 🏞️
    Southern Kettle Moraine State Forest borders the village directly — John Muir and Emma Carlin trail systems start within minutes of most homes.
  • 🏛️
    Old World Wisconsin, one of the largest outdoor living history museums in the U.S., sits just southeast of the village on Hwy 67.
  • 🚗
    About 35–40 miles southwest of Milwaukee via I-43 or US-12 — a real commute. Drive your route at rush hour before deciding.
  • 🎓
    Palmyra-Eagle Area School District: elementary school in the village, middle and high school in Palmyra (~8 miles). Verify your boundary by address.
  • 🏡
    Rural character throughout: older village homes, acreage parcels outside limits, and limited new construction — most inventory is established.

Neighborhoods & Lifestyle Profiles

Most Eagle searches come down to lifestyle and property type. Compare the village core for walkable convenience, quieter residential pockets for space, and newer subdivisions when layout, garage space, and lower near-term maintenance are priorities.

📍 Village Core

Established homes along Eagle’s original street grid — practical for buyers who want walkable proximity to the community center and village services without a rural property’s maintenance demands.

  • Smaller lots, mature tree canopy
  • Mix of older bungalows and updated ranches
  • Strong fit for first-time buyers and downsizers

🌲 Forest-Edge Properties

Homes backing to or neighboring Kettle Moraine State Forest land — the highest-demand addresses in Eagle for buyers who want trail access and natural surroundings as part of daily life.

  • Larger lots, wooded settings common
  • Immediate John Muir and Ice Age Trail access
  • Limited turnover; verify acreage and septic condition

🏗️ Rural Parcels & Acreage

Unincorporated Eagle area properties on larger lots — common for buyers seeking horse acreage, pole barns, or rural privacy that the village core can’t offer.

  • 1–10+ acre parcels available
  • Septic, well, and private road conditions vary
  • Lower price per acre vs. Mukwonago or Waukesha

Schools & Community Resources

🎓 Palmyra-Eagle Area School District

  • Eagle Elementary School — serves K–5 in the village of Eagle
  • Palmyra-Eagle Middle School — grades 6–8, located in Palmyra (~8 miles)
  • Palmyra-Eagle High School — grades 9–12, located in Palmyra
  • Smaller district with strong community ties — verify assignment by exact address before offering

🤝 Community Resources

  • Eagle Village Hall and community center host year-round programs and local events
  • Town of Eagle parks provide additional outdoor access separate from the state forest
  • Nearby Dousman and Mukwonago offer expanded library, recreation, and youth sports options
  • Waukesha County services available — confirm utility providers and tax info by parcel
School Note: Middle and high school students commute to Palmyra — factor this into daily schedule planning, especially for families with multiple school-age children.
Property Taxes: Waukesha County mill rates vary by municipality. Confirm the exact tax bill on any property before writing an offer.

Local Favorites & Weekend Picks

Before touring homes in Eagle, look at the daily-life details: grocery access, restaurants, parks, commute routes, youth activities, and weekend destinations. For Eagle buyers, proximity to Old World Wisconsin and the village center can matter as much as square footage once you are comparing similar homes.

🏛️ Old World Wisconsin

  • One of the largest outdoor living history museums in the U.S. — right on Hwy 67 at Eagle’s edge
  • Seasonal programming, heritage festivals, and working 19th-century farm sites
  • A major regional draw that defines Eagle’s identity as a destination community

🌲 Kettle Moraine Trails

  • John Muir Trail System — mountain biking and hiking, trailhead minutes from the village
  • Emma Carlin Trail System — additional off-road biking and hiking in the southern unit
  • Ice Age National Scenic Trail — multiple Eagle-area access points through the state forest

☕ Daily Life & Nearby Services

  • Eagle village has limited retail — Dousman (~5 min) and Mukwonago (~12 min) cover grocery, pharmacy, and dining
  • Waukesha (~20 min) provides the full suburban service suite for larger shopping and medical
  • A deliberate tradeoff: buyers choose space and setting over walkable amenities

Eagle Real Estate FAQs

What school district serves Eagle, WI?

Eagle is served by the Palmyra-Eagle Area School District. Eagle Elementary is in the village; Palmyra-Eagle Middle and High School are in Palmyra, about 8 miles away. Always verify your exact school assignment by address before writing an offer — district boundaries can split even within a small community.

How far is Eagle from Milwaukee?

Eagle is roughly 35–40 miles southwest of Milwaukee, primarily via I-43 northbound or US-12 east. Plan on 45–60 minutes in normal traffic — longer during peak commute hours. Drive your actual route at rush hour before committing to a property.

Are acreage and rural properties common in Eagle?

Yes — Eagle has one of the stronger rural parcel inventories in Waukesha County given its proximity to the Kettle Moraine State Forest and limited suburban development. Properties range from standard village lots to 5+ acre parcels with pole barns and pasture. Septic and well conditions vary widely; a thorough inspection is essential.

What makes Eagle different from Mukwonago or Wales?

Eagle is significantly more rural than both. Mukwonago offers more retail, restaurants, and recreation within the city; Wales skews more suburban. Eagle trades walkable convenience for direct forest adjacency, lower density, and a removed lifestyle. Buyers who want that tradeoff find few comparable options in Waukesha County at similar price points.

Featured Eagle Listings

Browse active Eagle, WI listings below, then contact Kaplon Realty for private showing help, pricing context, and offer strategy tailored to this market.

Why Tour With Kaplon Realty

  • Priority tour scheduling to stay ahead of weekend traffic
  • Trusted inspector and lender referrals when you’re ready to move
  • Rural acreage, septic, and well expertise for smooth closings
  • Off-market intel across Eagle and neighboring communities

Search updated MLS listings below — refreshed multiple times daily for Eagle.

Eagle WI Real Estate: A Local Guide

Work With an Eagle Real Estate Specialist

Ready to tour homes near Old World Wisconsin or prep your property for sale? We bring Eagle market knowledge, pricing precision, and hands-on support to every client.

Contact Kaplon Realty Get a Home Valuation Browse Current Listings

Prefer to call? Reach us at 262-498-6751.

Eagle Buyer Planning Checklist

  • Compare Eagle neighborhoods by commute, lot size, and price-per-square-foot range.
  • Verify property taxes, HOA terms, and utility setup before finalizing offer terms.
  • Review common inspection priorities in Eagle homes before contingency deadlines.
  • Benchmark nearby alternatives in Waukesha County when weekly inventory is tight.

Related Areas